Jeff, I agree with your statement that continuing education is very important
I'm a big advocate for higher certifications for volunteers (even though I haven't made it to I-B or I-C yet

) and I started a thread on this very subject back when these state forums were first put up. Since then, I have changed my opinion slightly:
The Michigan county just to the north of me requires ALL of their firefighters to complete FFII (240) within 2 years of being hired (paid) or joining (volunteers).
That being said, my department (most of us only have 36 hours) can run circles around some of their departments on the fireground. And I don't mean to sound arrogant when I say that.
I feel the reason is we have required weekly 3 hour drills that build on what we were taught in the 36 hour class and much of the info taught in FFII is learned that way.
Yes, the 240 looks great on paper and inititally you will be much better trained than a 36 hour firefighter but you must have continuing education throughout your career.
Yes, FFI or even II would be great for volunteers but I now feel that a continuing education requirement similar to EMS would be even better.