1. #1
    Forum Member

    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    USA baby
    Posts
    172

    Post Dawn soap in tank?

    So an idea was presented by one of our members. Basically when one of our pumpers needs a wetting agent (like class a foam) to just dump a gallon of dawn dish soap into the water tank. It would only be used in situations in which the entire tank could be used, and then thoroughly flushed. IE interface fires in which pumpers are being used along with brush trucks. We tend to have a fair amount of these. So my question here is if anyone has done this before. The theory is that we just need something to reduce the surface tension of the water, and dawn should do the trick well enough to emulate class A foam. Any feedback? My initial response was negative, but as long as the soap doesn't damage the pump it might not be a bad idea.
    Fire Service Interview questions - The blog that has REAL interview questions for firefighters, Engineers, Lieutenants, and Captains !

  2. #2
    Forum Member
    Chenzo's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Rural WI
    Posts
    1,231

    Default

    If I remember correctly, this was done years ago when foam was damn expensive. I don't know about pump damage, but I would bet one of the older, wiser folks on here will weigh in on this, but if I remember correctly it has been done before.

  3. #3
    MembersZone Subscriber
    tajm611's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Posts
    2,071
    ‎"I was always taught..." Four words impacting fire service education in the most negative of ways. -Bill Carey

  4. #4
    MembersZone Subscriber
    Dickey's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2000
    Location
    Wisconsin
    Posts
    5,111

    Default

    JT_Fire_2000...

    If you are just looking to "soften" your water a bit so it is easier to do some overhaul or penetrate a bit nicer for brush/grass fires, yes, a dishwashing detergent such as Dawn will do the trick. We used to put a squirt in each pack can, the old aluminum "Indian Cans." It kept the handle nice and lubricated and worked well for penetrating.

    However, there is no substitute for real Class A foam. Dawn does not have the firefighting properties that Class A foam has meaning it doesn't last as long and isn't designed to make the shaving cream type thicker foam for exposure protection or making fire lines.

    Also, check with your pump manufacturer. Over time it may damage some pump parts and seals depending on what they use. I know in CAFS systems they certainly don't recommend it.
    Jason Knecht
    Assistant Chief
    Altoona Fire Dept.
    Altoona, WI

    IACOJ - Director of Cheese and Whine
    http://www.cheddarvision.tv/
    EAT CHEESE OR DIE!!

  5. #5
    MembersZone Subscriber
    LVFD301's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jun 2006
    Posts
    3,956

    Default

    Works really well in brush trucks on brush and wildland cover fires.

  6. #6
    Forum Member
    FIREMECH1's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    HUSKER LAND
    Posts
    2,425

    Default

    Any brand of hand liquid dish washing soap will not harm the pump or seals.

    As for CAFS systems, it isn't a good idea.

    FM1
    I'm the one Fire and Rescue calls, when they need to be Rescued.

    Quote Originally Posted by EastKyFF
    "Firemens gets antsies. Theys wants to goes to fires. Sometimeses they haves to waits."

  7. #7
    Forum Member

    Join Date
    Jan 2007
    Posts
    2,802

    Default

    get the antibacterial dish soap and you can use it for flushes

  8. #8
    Forum Member

    Join Date
    May 2007
    Posts
    441

    Default

    You can buy REAL CL A foam for $60-65 per 5gal pail. Do the math on moms kitchen detergent. It's more expensive to buy the pretend stuff at Kmart.

    Hint: 128oz/gallon

  9. #9
    MembersZone Subscriber
    tree68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Jefferson County, NY USA
    Posts
    2,287

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by fireinfo10 View Post
    You can buy REAL CL A foam for $60-65 per 5gal pail. Do the math on moms kitchen detergent. It's more expensive to buy the pretend stuff at Kmart.

    Hint: 128oz/gallon
    That only applies if you're dumping 26 bottles (24 oz) into a five gallon bucket and sucking that into the eductor.

    Last time we used dishwashing detergent for foam training, it was more like one bottle of detergent into a five gallon bucket of water. Even using two bottles in a 5 gallon bucket puts the cost at under $10 for five gallons of foam solution. Make sure you mix it well before using.

    We got lots of foam out of it. The goal at the time was familiarity with our foam equipment, not extinguishing fires, but a few weeks later we had a grass fire that had gotten into what was left of a collapsed outbuilding and the same basic solution worked well for penetration.

    From another thread linked above, SilverCity said they put in 8 oz per 200 gallons, which is like .03% Extending that to putting just under two 24 oz bottles into a 1000 gallon tank, and extrapolating over to the two 24 oz bottles in 5 gallons of water, you'd have to run the eductor at around 4% to get the same mixture at the nozzle (if I got my math right).

    The bottom line is that until you get to mixing 13 (24 oz) bottles of dish soap into five gallons of water, you're still cheaper with the dishsoap than with the class A foam (depending on what dish soap you use and how much you spend on it).
    Opinions my own. Standard disclaimers apply.

    Everyone goes home. Safety begins with you.

  10. #10
    Forum Member
    RollerDJ's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2011
    Posts
    20

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by tree68 View Post
    That only applies if you're dumping 26 bottles (24 oz) into a five gallon bucket and sucking that into the eductor.

    Last time we used dishwashing detergent for foam training, it was more like one bottle of detergent into a five gallon bucket of water. Even using two bottles in a 5 gallon bucket puts the cost at under $10 for five gallons of foam solution. Make sure you mix it well before using.

    We got lots of foam out of it. The goal at the time was familiarity with our foam equipment, not extinguishing fires, but a few weeks later we had a grass fire that had gotten into what was left of a collapsed outbuilding and the same basic solution worked well for penetration.

    From another thread linked above, SilverCity said they put in 8 oz per 200 gallons, which is like .03% Extending that to putting just under two 24 oz bottles into a 1000 gallon tank, and extrapolating over to the two 24 oz bottles in 5 gallons of water, you'd have to run the eductor at around 4% to get the same mixture at the nozzle (if I got my math right).

    The bottom line is that until you get to mixing 13 (24 oz) bottles of dish soap into five gallons of water, you're still cheaper with the dishsoap than with the class A foam (depending on what dish soap you use and how much you spend on it).
    I've never seen dish soap used before, but i know one of the neighboring stations uses it from time to time in their brish truck. How does it compaire to the CAFS system? I've seen that used first hand at our station, (we have one engine that has a CAFS setup) how would you compaire the two?

  11. #11
    MembersZone Subscriber
    tree68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Jefferson County, NY USA
    Posts
    2,287

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by RollerDJ View Post
    I've never seen dish soap used before, but i know one of the neighboring stations uses it from time to time in their brish truck. How does it compaire to the CAFS system? I've seen that used first hand at our station, (we have one engine that has a CAFS setup) how would you compaire the two?
    We don't use a lot of foam, A or B, and don't have CAFS.

    Check the links provided further up the thread - there's some pretty good info there.
    Opinions my own. Standard disclaimers apply.

    Everyone goes home. Safety begins with you.

  12. #12
    Forum Member
    IronValor's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2011
    Location
    Richmond, Kentucky
    Posts
    210

    Default

    We have used dish soap in our Wildland unit before. Works pretty well actually and there has not been any damage to our pump. However I probably would use Class A Foam for a structure or Vehicle fire if thats what is in you SOP.
    Do not let the ghosts of our fallen brothers gaze upon you and ask " What have you done to my profession?" FTB DTRT EGH

  13. #13
    MembersZone Subscriber
    sdff1520's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    SD
    Posts
    322

    Default

    Let me see if I did my math correctly?

    5 gallon pail of good quality class A foam "DESIGNED' for firefighting = $70.00 or $14 per gallon, or $0.11 per ounce.

    Dawn dishsoap in a 24 ounce bottle is $5.79 = $0.24 per ounce.

    We normally run our foam systems at .3% (3 tenths of a percent) injection rate so for every 100 gallons of water we use 38.4 ounces of foam concentrate.

    So it costs $4.22 cents to treat 100 gallons of water with actual class A foam concentrate and $9.22 cents to treat 100 gallons of water with dish soap, assuming equal concentrations.

    Why not just run actual foam concentrate and in addition to making a better foam (bubbles) you also reap the benefits of actual class A fire fighting foam. It works better as a wetting agent, is designed to be hydrocarbon loving. Also biodegradable and environmentally friendly just to name a few of the long list of benefits. You will have more impressive results ounce for ounce using actual class A foam concentrate as compared to dishsoap.

  14. #14
    Forum Member
    MemphisE34a's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2004
    Location
    Memphis, TN - USA
    Posts
    2,526

    Default

    It probably works best if you have a lot of dishes that need cleaned.
    RK
    cell #901-494-9437

    Management is making sure things are done right. Leadership is doing the right thing. The fire service needs alot more leaders and a lot less managers.

    "Everyone goes home" is the mantra for the pussification of the modern, American fire service.


    Comments made are my own. They do not represent the official position or opinion of the Fire Department or the City for which I am employed. In fact, they are normally exactly the opposite.

  15. #15
    MembersZone Subscriber
    tree68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Jefferson County, NY USA
    Posts
    2,287

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by sdff1520 View Post
    Let me see if I did my math correctly?

    5 gallon pail of good quality class A foam "DESIGNED' for firefighting = $70.00 or $14 per gallon, or $0.11 per ounce.

    Dawn dishsoap in a 24 ounce bottle is $5.79 = $0.24 per ounce.
    While I agree that going with class A foam is the best solution (pun intended), what we don't know is the relative concentrations of detergent in class A foam and dish soap.

    You cite $0.11 per ounce of firefighting-ready class A foam. No dilution necessary to be eductor-ready.

    You cite $0.24 per ounce of dishwashing [/i]concentrate[/i] - but we don't know what the proper dilution would be to make it more or less equivalent to bona fide class A foam (let's just assume that we're just talking about making suds for practice - not its effectiveness as a firefighting agent). If we can dilute the dishsoap 4:1 to make an equivalent eductor-ready solution the effective price drops to $0.06 per ounce, or about half that of class A foam.

    That's about one 24 ounce bottle of dishwashing soap per gallon of water, or $5.79 vs $14.00.

    Until we can figure out the equivalency, we really can't discuss relative cost.

    And while we can agree that actual class A foam is the most desireable, it's apparent that folks have found dishwashing soap to be a viable solution for some applications, besides washing dishes.

    MemphisE34a - Have you been to my house?
    Opinions my own. Standard disclaimers apply.

    Everyone goes home. Safety begins with you.

  16. #16
    MembersZone Subscriber
    sdff1520's Avatar
    Join Date
    Sep 2001
    Location
    SD
    Posts
    322

    Default

    Very true regarding dilution of the dishsoap. But I'm focusing more on the actual benefits provided as it pertains to actual fire suppression (not just the creation of bubbles). While we haven't done any measurable scientific studies it has been my experience that ounce per ounce, class A concentrate outperforms dishshoap at actually extinguishing, preventing re-kindle and wetting class A fuels. If just making bubbles is the goal, by all means, use whatever makes the most bubbles for the $. But there is more going on in regard to fire extinguishment than making good bubbles, some of the effectiveness of actual foam concentrate can't be measured by looking only at bubble production, lots of things going on that can't be 'seen'.

  17. #17
    MembersZone Subscriber
    tree68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Jefferson County, NY USA
    Posts
    2,287

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by sdff1520 View Post
    lots of things going on that can't be 'seen'.
    True that.
    Opinions my own. Standard disclaimers apply.

    Everyone goes home. Safety begins with you.

  18. #18
    MembersZone Subscriber
    firefighterbeau's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Central ND USA
    Posts
    451

    Default

    My home town dept used to use Dawn in the tank of the truck, we used 2 bottles 20oz (not sure on size exactly but they were the smaller bottles) in a 750 gallon tank, its just enough to create a film and break that surface tension of water. As stated before it does not create a blanket of foam, and do not expect it to, but it worked great, on brush fires and mop up. It did tear packings out of the Bean High pressure unit if at least 2 tanks of clean water was not run through the truck. If you run any type of detergent through any pump you have to flush it all out, or the seals and packings could be damaged.

  19. #19
    MembersZone Subscriber

    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Location
    N.W. Iowa
    Posts
    196

    Default

    We use Dawn in out grass trucks all the time, works well on grass and brush fires.

  20. #20
    Forum Member

    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Posts
    600

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by firefighterbeau View Post
    My home town dept used to use Dawn in the tank of the truck, we used 2 bottles 20oz (not sure on size exactly but they were the smaller bottles) in a 750 gallon tank, its just enough to create a film and break that surface tension of water. As stated before it does not create a blanket of foam, and do not expect it to, but it worked great, on brush fires and mop up. It did tear packings out of the Bean High pressure unit if at least 2 tanks of clean water was not run through the truck. If you run any type of detergent through any pump you have to flush it all out, or the seals and packings could be damaged.
    Packings in a John Bean pump? You are probably referring to the "cups." Totally different concept. The cups in the Bean pump were the pistons. There were no "packings," in the traditional sense. But, those cups have direct contact with the cylinder wall and are self-lubricated. It is easy to believe that any kind of detergent would shorten their lives.

    I am not advocating high pressure but, that Bean pump could really kick some donkey, couldn't it? The fog pattern could darn near create a cloud and the straight stream could cut wood. The 3/4" hose was half the weight of regular 1" booster hose. And, the nozzleman still had a reliable 30 GPM at his disposal.

    As for the topic at hand, I sure wish some of the pros from the foam companies would chime in. It would be interesting to hear what they have to say. One thing is certain, if a cheap bottle of dish soap is as effective as class A on wildland fires, we can expect more regulations to prevent its use.

    Just sayin'.

  21. #21
    Forum Member

    Join Date
    Mar 2011
    Posts
    29

    Default

    yeah me too..

  22. #22
    MembersZone Subscriber
    firefighterbeau's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2003
    Location
    Central ND USA
    Posts
    451

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by firepundit View Post
    Packings in a John Bean pump? You are probably referring to the "cups." Totally different concept. The cups in the Bean pump were the pistons. There were no "packings," in the traditional sense. But, those cups have direct contact with the cylinder wall and are self-lubricated. It is easy to believe that any kind of detergent would shorten their lives.

    I am not advocating high pressure but, that Bean pump could really kick some donkey, couldn't it? The fog pattern could darn near create a cloud and the straight stream could cut wood. The 3/4" hose was half the weight of regular 1" booster hose. And, the nozzleman still had a reliable 30 GPM at his disposal.

    As for the topic at hand, I sure wish some of the pros from the foam companies would chime in. It would be interesting to hear what they have to say. One thing is certain, if a cheap bottle of dish soap is as effective as class A on wildland fires, we can expect more regulations to prevent its use.

    Just sayin'.
    Thanks for the correction, on the Bean pump yes i was referring to the ''Cups''.

    I love those old Bean pumps, great on grass fires, and in certain other situations such as mop up.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. World Of Fire Report: 01-25-05
    By PaulBrown in forum World of Fire Daily Report
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 01-26-2005, 10:24 PM
  2. Anyone ever tried a wheeled porta tank?
    By neiowa in forum Apparatus Innovation
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 06-13-2004, 02:07 PM
  3. Tank Recovery
    By NJFFSA16 in forum Specialized Rescue
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 04-27-2002, 06:27 AM
  4. AFFF or FFFP
    By Lallo in forum Firefighters Forum
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 03-18-2002, 08:34 PM
  5. RFP's
    By D Littrell in forum Apparatus Innovation
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 09-08-2000, 06:36 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Log in

Click here to log in or register