Why register? ...To Enhance Your Experience
Closed Thread
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 34

Thread: FEMA Grants

  1. #1
    MembersZone Subscriber pres41's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Carlisle Penna
    Posts
    53

    Default FEMA Grants

    Am I wrong but do I see a large portion of these grants going to California, there seems to be a growing trend here. I just finished a sampling of both rounds of grants by state and no other state can touch California for the amount and size of grants. And, damn if those Paid Depts are that poor we volunteers are in real trouble. Looks like another goverment farce. O Well so much for us old east coast volunteer departments
    Pres41 (Pete)
    pres41@aol.com


  2. #2
    Forum Member jmkfire's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2001
    Location
    Riley, Kansas
    Posts
    302

    Default

    I agree. It also looks like Florida and Texas are fairing pretty well themselves. I bet you could add all the grants that were awarded to the Midwest areas, such as KS, NE, IA, MO, OK, SD and they wouldn't total what the three states have recieved. Probably wouldn't total CA count. I know that only two depts. in KS have recieved grants from the first two rounds. There wasn't one in the first round. It's becoming a little bit disheartening while we sit and wait to here something for our small Vol. dept. Well, maybe hear something next week
    Be safe!

    "Just remember. No matter where you go. There you are!"

  3. #3
    Senior Member Dalmatian90's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    3,120

    Default

    Gosh, imagine that...
    States with Big Populations getting most of the money.

    California -- the most populus state at 33.8 million.
    Texas #2 at 20.8 million.
    Florida #4 at 15.9 million.

    KS has 2.7 million
    NE has 1.7 million
    IA has 2.9 miilion
    MO has 5.3 million
    OK has 3.4 million
    SD has 0.8 million
    Combined that's 16.8 million people -- not much bigger than Florida, less than half of California.

    I'd expect those big three states to get about 4 times as much as those small states listed, as they have four times the people to protect.

    The grants are already being award 43% Career/57% Volunteer or Combination based on the % of the US Population protected by each -- so you're not going to see a huge slant towards rural areas. Career departments have better odds, since while there is a lot fewer departments protecting their 43%, while there is a lot more vollie departments numerically to carve up their 57%.
    IACOJ Canine Officer
    20/50

  4. #4
    MembersZone Subscriber pres41's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Carlisle Penna
    Posts
    53

    Default

    Yes the bigger states have a higher population, but they also have a higher number of paid depts and if they protect a higher number of people then their tax base should be higher also thus more moneys available, the truley needy volunteer Depts in the small and rural states get screwed again
    Pres41 (Pete)
    pres41@aol.com

  5. #5
    Member Plug-Ugly's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2001
    Location
    northeast USA
    Posts
    34

    Default

    Everything is relative.

    More people = more fires = more equipment = more maitenance costs = more money, and on, and on it goes.

    If your department is lucky enough to get a grant this time, good for you. If you don't get one, tough sh--. Maybe next time, but don't begrudge the ones who do get it.

  6. #6
    Senior Member ENG6511's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    174

    Default

    Dalmation 90, Please don't screw up the "emotion" of the thread with FACTS that spoil the whole argument.
    Bob Compton
    IACOJ-Proud
    IACOJ-HALL OF FAME-2003

  7. #7
    Senior Member Dalmatian90's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    3,120

    Default

    Yes the bigger states have a higher population, but they also have a higher number of paid depts and if they protect a higher number of people then their tax base should be higher also thus more moneys available, the truley needy volunteer Depts in the small and rural states get screwed again

    Huh?

    At the risk of once again ruining a perfectly good thread with facts and figures (sorry, it's raining so I can't go out and mow the lawn...)

    Per Capita Income
    CA $22,439
    TX $19,857
    FL $21,677

    The Small States:
    KS $20,869
    NE $20,448
    IA $20,265
    MO $20,717
    OK $17,744
    SD $19,577

    Hmmm, most of those small states have per-capita income within $1,000 +/- of the big states.

    If you adjust for cost of living between states like California with high housing and energy costs and more affordable mid and southwestern states, the actual differences become in the hundreds of dollars.

    For instance, it costs 21% less to live in Oklahoma City than Sacremento (which is still a reasonable to live in part of CA) while maintaining the same lifestyle. In other words, $22,439 in Sacremento is the same as $17,726 in OK City. Which actually places the "high" state below the "low" state in what you can actually buy with your income.

    All taxes, in the end, are income taxes. Whether they're called property taxes, sales taxes, estate taxes or whatever, if you don't earn it or have it, you can't pay it.

    I don't see a big difference between the citizens of the big and small states to pay for their own fire protection.
    IACOJ Canine Officer
    20/50

  8. #8
    MembersZone Subscriber pres41's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2001
    Location
    Carlisle Penna
    Posts
    53

    Default

    I know for a fact of one application that went in from a small vol dept in the midwest and all they ask for was $3200 to buy a 24' ext ladder, and 14' roof ladder 2 axes some pike poles and all this for their 1944 Buffalo pumper, anybody want to take bets on this one. But hey those little old volunteer depts have as big a tax base as the big paid depts, so I'm told, how many paid depts do you know that are still running a 1944 Buffalo pumper as a first line piece
    Pres41 (Pete)
    pres41@aol.com

  9. #9
    Forum Member
    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Location
    Darien CT USA
    Posts
    63

    Default

    Rather than get annoyed that we didn't get our slice of the pie why don't we just be glad that we even had a chance to get some of this pie.

    Never in our history has such a large sum of cash been available to the fire service and from how it looks now, another round of grants will be issued next year as well.

    Stop complaining and be glad that we're starting to get some support from the government.

    - Turk II

  10. #10
    MembersZone Subscriber killerb's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2001
    Posts
    139

    Default

    With less than 10% of the total awards announced so far, isn't it a little too soon to start analyzing it?

    The fewer samples you look at, the higher the "wag" factor.

    Asst. Chief Bill
    Asst. Chief Bill

    International Order of the Fraternal Brotherhood of the Club

    Somewhere in or near north central Creek County, Oklahoma

  11. #11
    Forum Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    33

    Default

    I dunno, but our Dept. got close to $15,000 in the first round and that is great. So far, I think we are one of the two or three depts. in CT to get anything, lucked out I guess. We are hoping for more, would be nice, but hey, this is the first year of the grant, hopefully it continues, and our @$$ hole of a president never had to give us anything. Just remember, it's not over yet.
    "WAS THAT BEFORE OR AFTER YOU REALIZED YOU WERE STANDING IN A $#@%*&% PUDDLE OF GASOLINE?"

  12. #12
    Senior Member hctrouble25's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Location
    NJ, USA
    Posts
    356

    Default

    I too am grateful for the grant money we were given. However, I agree that some larger departments with more money and resources available to them (i.e. Viriginia Beach VA) are getting more money than some of the departments that need it. The money is awarded based on the type of grant application you sent in along with the need you showed for the money. Larger departments can afford to pay someone to write a fancy application for them. For my department it was the first time we had ever applied for something like this and we were very confused and did our best to make our case but were not sure if what we did was good enough or not. Also, I don't thank the feds for this because they give millions of dollars annually to paid police departments all over the country....they act like they are doing us a favor by giving us money for fire protection. (For more info read what Pres. Bush wrote when he took this money away from us by going to the FEMA website)Most police departments are covered in taxes...many volunteer companies are not and we have to do fund raisers constantly to raise money..I don't see the local and State Police doing that. The feds need to take us more seriously. They will when we are all paid and the citizens are bitching about having to pay 5-10% taxes per year to pay us for fire protection. I realized early on that my department probably would not get any of this money, but we did try and that is all we could do. I wish you all the best of luck in getting the money you applied for...and hopefully the feds will start to see a serious need for this money to be handed out annually. Take care.
    Never forget those who went before and sacrified to make us better and stronger as a fire service and a nation. 09-11-01 forever etched in time and our memories. God Speed Boys!

  13. #13
    MembersZone Subscriber
    Join Date
    Jul 2001
    Location
    Silver City, Oklahoma USA
    Posts
    985

    Default

    The money is going to go to:
    1) departments who applied (Dal90, got any stats on how many departments from different states applied?)
    2) departments that demostrated a need
    3) where the money will do the most good for the most people

    Higher populated areas are going to be able to demostrate that the money would be put to better use in their area. Not to degrade the small volunteer departments. We applied too, but we protect 500 people. My hopes aren't real high.

    And on a note about the funding in general...

    I'd rather have more of my taxes back than have the Fire Grant. But it's there, so we'll apply. As for the fact that law enforcement gets (and has had) support from the federal government, I don't think the solution is to INCREASE federal money for fire departments. I think that the federal government should DECREASE federal money for law enforcement.

    Local issues are best dealt with on the local level.

    [ 08-06-2001: Message edited by: Silver City 4 ]
    Bryan Beall
    Silver City, Oklahoma USA

  14. #14
    Senior Member Dalmatian90's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    3,120

    Default

    Most police departments are covered in taxes...many volunteer companies are not and we have to do fund raisers constantly to raise money..

    Then quit whining and get tax support.

    Ya, ok, I know some areas even the taxes would be insufficient.

    But insufficient in New Jersey? Or Connecticut, or most of Pennsylvania or New York?

    Even in less populated areas, insufficient on County-wide or State-wide areas?

    They will when we are all paid and the citizens are bitching about having to pay 5-10% taxes per year to pay us for fire protection.

    Well, either your community has really good tax revenues or your really under-estimating paid fire protection costs.

    Volunteer funding in my area is about 3-5% of the total town mill rate; you'd be looking at 20-30% to fund minimal career paid departments. In my town of 7,000 the minimal staffing for a paid department (not doing EMS transports, and no where close to 1710 levels) would be the same size as our Junior High School teaching staff! In other words, ain't gonna happen.

    Of course, we have almost no local police in our area either -- my town has 2 contract state troopers, and the neighboring town of 18,000 runs with 4 contracted state troopers.
    IACOJ Canine Officer
    20/50

  15. #15
    Senior Member hctrouble25's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2000
    Location
    NJ, USA
    Posts
    356

    Default

    Most police departments are covered in taxes...many volunteer companies are not and we have to do fund raisers constantly to raise money..

    **Then quit whining and get tax support.**

    NOT WHINING, JUST STATING FACTS. WE CANNOT GET TAX SUPPORT JUST BY SAYING WE WANT IT, THE TOWNSHIP WOULD HAVE TO MANDATE THAT. THE ONLY WAY TO GET THEM TO DO THIS WOULD BE TO HAVE ALL THE DEPARTMENTS IN THE TOWNSHIP STOP SHOWING UP FOR CALLS...I DON'T SEE THAT HAPPENING. MY PARENTS LIVE IN THE TOWN I PROTECT AND I SURE AS HELL WOULD NOT STAY HOME IF I HEARD THEIR HOUSE WAS ON FIRE. AND MANY OF OUR MEMBERS LIVE IN TOWN AND WOULDN'T LET THEIR NEIGHBORS HOMES OR THEIR OWN HOMES BURN DOWN EITHER. THE TOWNSHIPS KNOW WE WON'T STOP RESPONDING SO THEY HOLD IT OVER US. THEY GET FIRE PROTECTION WITHOUT HAVING TO PAY OUT MUCH MONEY AND THEY LIKE IT THAT WAY.

    Ya, ok, I know some areas even the taxes would be insufficient. But insufficient in New Jersey? Or Connecticut, or most of Pennsylvania or New York?

    YES. REMEMBER IN NJ AND PA THERE ARE A LOT OF RURAL AREAS. THE TOWN I WORK IN IS VERY SMALL BUT WE COVER AREAS OF 3 TOWNSHIPS OUT HERE COVERING 27 SQUARE MILES. THE 3 TOWNSHIPS SPLIT THE MONEY BETWEEN THE DEPARTMENTS THAT COVER THEM SO EVERYONE ALWAYS GET JIPPED OUT OF MONEY - THEY SAY THEY BASE IT ON NUMBER OF CALLS RUN BUT THAT IS NOT ALWAYS THE CASE. BELIEVE ME I AM NOT BITCHING, LIKE I SAID I AM HAPPY THE FEDS GAVE US SOME MONEY FINALLY. THE PROBLEM IS THAT I SEE SOME DEPARTMENTS GETTING MONEY THAT DON'T NEED IT AS BADLY AS OTHERS. LIKE I SAID...VIRIGINA BEACH VA?! PLEASE THEY HAVE TONS OF MONEY COMING IN...

    VA BEACH Fire Department demographics

    $28 Million annual Budget
    Combination Department
    Twenty Fire Stations
    FEMA US&R-Virgina Task Force Two
    Urban Technical Search and Rescue team
    Hazardous Materials Team
    Incident Response Team

    WHAT IS THAT OLD SAYING? "MONEY GOES TO MONEY"? HEY, GOOD FOR THEM THAT THEY GOT MONEY, BUT BAD FOR US POOR DEPARTMENTS THAT DIDN'T AND WON'T BE ABLE TO BUY A BADLY NEEDED NEW TRUCK OR SAFETY EQUIPMENT FOR MEMBERS. THAT IS JUST REALITY FOR SOME OF US. SO PLEASE DON'T TELL ME TO STOP WHINING. STAY SAFE OUT THERE.
    Never forget those who went before and sacrified to make us better and stronger as a fire service and a nation. 09-11-01 forever etched in time and our memories. God Speed Boys!

  16. #16
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    Mar 2001
    Location
    Llano, Texas Llano
    Posts
    148

    Default

    Dalmation, i see that you live in Conn. down here in Texas, people do not what to pay more taxes. You have a major war on your hands if taxes go up and property values go up. We have to have several fund raisers durring the year. we have the oldest average in Texas and mabye the US. fixed incomes is the norm here and people fight against any tax raises. a friend of mine sent me some info of a fire department in Missouri and the tax rate for the fire district was 30 cents per 100.00 here in Texas, we can only levy 3 cents per hundred dollars for a fire district. An emergency services district can only levy 10 cents per 100 dollars. yalls tax bills must be hugh. maybe that is why everyone is moving to Texas to escape your taxes. if we had that large rate, even in our rural area we could raise 10 times as much money and have no need of fund raisers.
    we could purchase new equipment every year.
    Thanks for letting me spout off and please send us rain, we some relief from the heat and grass fires.Larry

  17. #17
    Senior Member Dalmatian90's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    3,120

    Default

    Gee, people only complain about taxes in Texas? Ask the boys from Massachussets about Prop 2 1/2 which limits municipal spending increases to 2.5% per year without a referendum to override.

    Rich? Hardly. My town's Mill Rate is 20.8 mills, or $20.80 per thousand of assesed value -- or $2.08 per hundred. 3/4 goes to the Schools along with a lot of state aid, and everything else in town gets by on the other 1/4 with a little bit of state aid.

    Fire Protection in total, including the Fire Companies, Fire Marshal, Capital spending, LOSAP, and fees to the privately owned water company come to about 1.5 mill, or 15 cents per hundred. That ain't far from you 10 cents per hundred limit! Most towns in the area run 1-2 mills for fire taxes.

    Grand List is $264 million, for a town of 7,000. Largest employer is the State Department of Corrections, and the 4th largest is a mom & pop restaurant, largest taxpayer is a shopping center consisting of a Bowling Alley, a NAPA, a Discount Job Lot department store, and a Salvation Army store. No, we're not poor. But we're hardly swimming in cash -- for that, one goes to Greenwich, CT

    When I joined 14 years ago, I was handed a canvas coat, an old-fashion (no bump cap) leather helmet, and a three year wait list for a pager. Running at the time trucks that where 10, 13, 17, and 39 years old.

    Nah, our taxpayers don't cry about tax increases. That's probably why our operating budget remained constant from 1988 to 1998, actually went down in 1999, and only in 2000 started to have modest increases.

    So, maybe I do know about not having money to spare.
    IACOJ Canine Officer
    20/50

  18. #18
    Senior Member Dalmatian90's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    3,120

    Default

    Yep, FEMA does have new math...
    The Firehouse posting of the grants so far add up to $15,000,000+, not the 7,000,000 listed (and I cut and paste direct to Excel, so it's not an error on my side!)
    Anyway:

    Actual Dollars:
    Bottom 5:
    CO -0-
    DE -0-
    HI -0-
    ID -0-
    NJ $18,131.00

    Top 5:
    ME $628,967.57
    OH $659,132.00
    IN $675,470.00
    MO $741,497.00
    CA $885,620.00
    TX $959,937.00

    Per Capita:
    Low 5:
    NJ $0.00
    MD $0.01
    AZ $0.01
    UT $0.02
    PA $0.02

    Top 5:
    SD $0.20
    MT $0.27
    AK $0.29
    WY $0.33
    ME $0.49

    Remember, there's only $0.32 per person nationwide to go around, so Wyoming and Maine only states that have made money so far.

    Number of Grants:
    Low 5 (after the zilch club)
    MD 1
    RI 1
    ND 1
    VT 1
    VA 2

    High 5
    NY 11
    KY 11
    IN 13
    CA 17
    TX 17

    Average Grant Size:
    Low 5 (excluding Zilch Gulch
    NJ $6,043.67
    UT $11,670.33
    AR $15,332.83
    IA $16,941.33
    AZ $21,024.33

    High 5:
    VA $92,000.00
    NC $106,255.80
    NE $111,150.00
    MO $123,582.83
    ME $125,793.51

    For the full spreadsheet, see http://www.mortlake.org/Miscfire/Fir...s/sheet003.htm

    The data was a direct cut and paste from the FEMA spreadsheet posted at http://www.firehouse.com/funding/fir...ecipients.html

    Matt
    IACOJ Canine Officer
    20/50

  19. #19
    Senior Member Dalmatian90's Avatar
    Join Date
    Mar 2000
    Posts
    3,120

    Default

    THAT IS JUST REALITY FOR SOME OF US. SO PLEASE DON'T TELL ME TO STOP WHINING. STAY SAFE OUT THERE.

    Ok, I won't tell you to stop whining this time. Please stop shouting.

    But I'm sorry, there is no place in New Jersey, nor Connecticut, where the tax-base can not support fire protection. By the way, my company protects 25 square miles with an ambulance area of 70 square miles -- so we're not quite a booming suburb up here in the sticks of northeastern CT. We're not talking about states with huge uninhabited lands, or sprawling low population ranches.

    Reality can change. It's called elections. Most rural towns, the Fire Company(s) are the second largest and the best organized group of people (the largest and not so organized is the Parent-Teacher Orgs). Start flexing. Change doesn't happen overnight, often only small changes happen year to year, but over the decades big changes occur.
    IACOJ Canine Officer
    20/50

  20. #20
    Senior Member
    Join Date
    May 2000
    Location
    DFW area of Texas
    Posts
    660

    Default

    pres41

    Looks like another goverment farce.

    Ya' think?

    How long did it take you to figure that out?

    JMKFIRE

    It also looks like Florida and Texas are fairing pretty well themselves.

    Nearly 2,300 fire departments in Texas. Are there more anywhere?

    pres41

    Yes the bigger states have a higher population, but they also have a higher number of paid depts

    Not necessarily.

    and if they protect a higher number of people then their tax base should be higher also thus more moneys available,

    Not necessarily, depends on the what the tax rate is.

    the truley needy volunteer Depts in the small and rural states get screwed again

    You sound surprised.

    Did you really think small departments were going to come out on top? Hell no, there ain't no votes in small towns. A vote buying scheme is wasted on small town America.

    Plug-Ugly

    If you don't get one, tough sh--.

    Yep

    Maybe next time, but don't begrudge the ones who do get it.

    Maybe a better idea is to dump the whole program, refund the money that is confiscated from the taxpayer to fund it back to the taxpayer so they can choose whether or not they want to support their local fire department.

    Dalmatian90

    I don't see a big difference between the citizens of the big and small states to pay for their own fire protection.

    YES!!!

    Each and every community in the US is funding their fire department to the level of protection/service they want. If they want more and are afraid to raise taxes, cut some of the BS government shouldn't be involved in anyway and send that money to the FD. Or, suck it up and raise the taxes LOCALLY.

    Turk II

    Stop complaining and be glad that we're starting to get some support from the government.

    You're not getting government support, the politicians are simply trying to buy your vote with yet another unConstitutional federal program payed for with money confiscated at gun point if necessary from hard working Americans - you and me.

    Jmatteau

    and our @$$ hole of a president never had to give us anything.

    What does the President owe us?

    Where in the Constitution, which you may recall sets the powers and duties of the Federal Government, are programs like the Fire Act authorized?

    Just remember, it's not over yet.

    Nope, they haven't bought enough votes yet...

    hctrouble25

    The feds need to take us more seriously.

    Why?

    Fire protection is a local issue.

    They will when we are all paid and the citizens are bitching about having to pay 5-10% taxes per year to pay us for fire protection.

    There's the solution to problems, call in the feds.

    Works everytime doesn't it...

    I'll ask again, (for everyone, not just you hctrouble) what has the federal government stuck its nose in and made it better?

    NOTHING.

    Some of our troops are on food stamps while prisoners get three hots and a cot. American Indians are treated like crap, our inner cities are a mess, medical care under the government sucks, your money is taken from you for your retirement drawing roughly 2% annually, but their own money draws 17% on average because they can opt out of SS. The war on drugs is still being fought and just keeps getting worse, people cared for by the feds are in despair.

    Washington DC is controlled by the feds. They have one of the highest crime and poverty rates in the nation.

    If they can't take care of their own house, how do you expect them to take care of yours?

    Would you rather send your money to your city and have the money put in the FD budget, or send it to the feds, have them confiscate what they want right off the top and then dole out the rest as they see fit?

    and hopefully the feds will start to see a serious need for this money to be handed out annually.

    Hopefully fire departmenst will WAKE UP and see the last thing we need is the feds in our face.

    Silver City 4

    I'd rather have more of my taxes back than have the Fire Grant. But it's there, so we'll apply. As for the fact that law enforcement gets (and has had) support from the federal government, I don't think the solution is to INCREASE federal money for fire departments. I think that the federal government should DECREASE federal money for law enforcement.

    Local issues are best dealt with on the local level.


    AMEN!

    Dalmatian90

    Then quit whining and get tax support.

    YES!

    hctrouble25

    WE CANNOT GET TAX SUPPORT JUST BY SAYING WE WANT IT,...THEY GET FIRE PROTECTION WITHOUT HAVING TO PAY OUT MUCH MONEY AND THEY LIKE IT THAT WAY.

    Not singling you out, but why is the lack of local funding in your, or any other town, the American taxpayers problem?

    Isn't it a local problem?

    LIKE I SAID...VIRIGINA BEACH VA?! PLEASE THEY HAVE TONS OF MONEY COMING IN...

    Like I said, this is a vote buying scheme pure and simple.

    Smell it all around you brothers and sisters, regardless of how you want to see it or spin it, the Fire Act is simply welfare for fire departments.

    WHAT IS THAT OLD SAYING? "MONEY GOES TO MONEY"?

    Part of the deal was you had to match part of the grant based on your population. If you couldn't match, you didn't get.

    Dalmatian90

    It's called elections. Most rural towns, the Fire Company(s) are the second largest and the best organized group of people (the largest and not so organized is the Parent-Teacher Orgs). Start flexing. Change doesn't happen overnight, often only small changes happen year to year, but over the decades big changes occur.

    Yep, the VFD in most communities can carry an election for mayor, city council, county commissioners, you name it.

    [ 08-06-2001: Message edited by: mongofire_99 ]
    It's only my opinion. I do not speak for any group or organization I belong to or associate with or people I know - especially my employer. If you like it, we can share it, you don't have to give me credit. If you don't, we are allowed to disagree too (but be ready to be challenged, you may be on to something I'm not). That's what makes America great!

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts