Just curious...which do prefer Holmatro?, Hurst? or Amkus? And why?
Just curious...which do prefer Holmatro?, Hurst? or Amkus? And why?
well, since my department doesn't have jaws yet, i like which ever set gets there first.
but of all the ones i have used i do like amkus.
Hey Engine21, shouldn't the title of this post say, "Holmatro, who and who?"!!!!
There is no other brand worth mentioning, other than Holmatro!:D
Now this thread is sure to stir the pot with a few people....! :p
Stir the pot?You Luke?I find this hard to believe!They are all good tools but I'll cast my vote for Holmatro as well.My prejudice is based on product familiarity and reliability.We've had a set for a long time and they've always done as we asked with no downtime.T.C.:cool:
I know hurst was big a few decades ago.
What's a holmatro?
The World´s Most Advanced Rescue Systems
Tough tools, not back-breakers (why do holmatro tools seem so darn heavy?)... an overall quality product that will not let you down. We used Lukas tools prior to switching to Amkus 5ish years ago. From my experiences with all of these tools, I'll take the Amkus systems any day. I like the controllers, how the tools are designed, and I most of all like the Ultimate system.
The Westerbeke/XRT unit is also kind of neat.
Supposedly TNT has a pump out that will kick the Amkus Ultimate System's *****... I'll believe it when I see it.
I have used Hurst, Amkus, Lukas, and Holmatro, pneumatic tools, K-12 and several others over the last 20 years. Right now I prefer Amkus. I had some power issues with our Holmatro tools a while back and have not been merciful enough to prefer it since. There is however a lot of simplicity in their tools, as well as their light weight technology. I need another good experience (perhaps in another TERC competition) with Holmatro in order to be pulled in to the holmatro fold again.
Hey Resq14, you must be having a lend of us! Holmatro heavy- I don't think so! You must be mixed up with Hurst!!!!:DQuote:
(why do holmatro tools seem so darn heavy?)
Ok, I need to come clean. I am a Holmatro fan as well. I just wanted to see where everyone was on the map, so to speak. The tools are high quality, light, and the company is outstanding to work with.
Just my two cents.
Facts & Figures About to be Introduced...
Amkus 30CX Spread: 32" Weight: 47.5#
Hurst ML-32 Spread: 32" Weight: 52#
Holmatro 3230 Spread: 33-3/8" Weight: 45#
Most of the tools are competetive when you compare apples-to-apples (or as close to that as possible) for spread and force. Hurst will always tend to weigh more, since they use low pressure (5000psi) and subsequently a little more bulk in their tools from using bigger pistons/hydraulics with more surface area to achieve the same forces (remember, pounds per square inch) as high pressure tools running at 10,000psi.
We're a Hurst department, can't justify the cost of junking our existing Hurst equipment to switch to a new company. Holmatro however I've cross-trained on with a neighboring department, and they'd be very competetive if we sat down and did a complete comparison to buy an all new system.
I said, "why do they seem so heavy" not "Amkus is the lightest tool ever made." I don't know if it is the way the tool is balanced or what, but imho, holmatro tools "feel" heavy. Maybe I was using an older model tool (I think it was relatively new though)
I was well aware of the weights... but it was nice to read them again anyhow.
These questions always get me.
"What's your favorite..."
"Which do you prefer..."
"Who makes the best..."
I like stirring the pot as much as the next guy, but there are always people that take it a little too seriously. New Scott Aviation SCBAs make you a Scott fan. New Pierces? Pierce fans. We're all biased here. Those who have been able to truly use the greatest variety of tools have more to draw on than those who have exposure to only 1 system (or none) in forming their opinion. Each manufacturer has its pros and its cons, ranging from performance, reliability, and construction down to service after the sale. You pick what you feel matches your identified needs and go from there.
The better question is, "What would you look for in a HRT system designed to operate X tools on Y trucks in Z department for $ dollars.
You want a spreader that will open while under a full load in 2 seconds? Write it into your spec. I'm not saying a manufacturer will be able to deliver on it, but you get the idea.
Then match your needs with the manufacturer who can deliver on them. If what you get fails to perform as spec'd, promised and/or advertised, then that is a different issue entirely.
All HRT systems work. The challenge is finding the one that will work best for YOU. Define your needs, then bounce them off the people here.
Who's prejudiced?Mwah?My other dept has Amkus,can't sell me.Familiarity is what works with your tools.Those Westerbeke's are sweet though.T.C.;)
I still stand behind the Hurst rescue tools. I have used the others but yes I still remember the old 32-A Jaws and used them a lot. Die hard Hurst tool user I guess. the air lifting bags are great too!!:)
i am sorry you have it all wrong TNT is the only choice! :D
For safety, durability and performance I choose Hurst. The others are just wana bees.
We have two sets of Amkus tools in service (actually, I think the older set might be Lukus...but that's the same thing, different company). We're going to have a third set in service in a month or so.
I've used Hurst, Holmatro, Amkus, and Lukus. I prefer the Amkus tools. I did like the Holmatro but at the end of my advanced vehicle extrication course, the cutters were completely dinged up. Of course, after I got home stupid me realized I forgot to take a picture of that. :eek:
I still like the Holmatro though, but I like Amkus better.
I have used Hurst, Amkus, Phoenix, Lukas, TNT, and some even oldie but goodies, overall I like Holmatro for dependability, weight, strength, Service and it is a US made tool. User preference has to be a factor, try them all then decide... :cool:
Never had my "orange"tool bog down.'Course I use dedicated tools with a dedicated pump not a combi but for power I'll go against your TNT any day.I've run TNT's,find them to be a very nice tool.But I have yet to find any reason to abandon my faithful Holmatro set.I've yet to find a spreader that has as much power start to finish as my good old orange tool.Yeah, my tools heavy,Holmatro doesn't make one bigger.But if you want in,you'll get in!Our company does heavy Rescue A-Z and opening any vehicle we've ever come across has never been a problem.Bogged down,NEVER,smooth performance start to finish.I don't think there are many "bad"HRTs from the major players,but I'm not sure I'd say the same about the operators and salesmen.Use what you are comfortable with,but in competition there doesn't seem to be a consistent winner,varies year to year.Indicates to me that tools are evolving just like the people who run them.T.C.
Before you start pointing fingers, you should check up on your history. Where did TNT get the ideas for their spreader and cutter? You weren't a distributor for TNT yet in 1995 but if you go back to 1995, you'll see that their patterns for the TNT spreader and cutter match what Lukas already had on the market as the LSP40B spreader and the LS300C cutter. Better get your facts straight before making accusations. :p
Phoenix all the way!:cool:
Phoenix - The true rescue tools! Zero to 60" in 3 tools!