Report: Mistakes By Chicago Firefighters Helped Lead To Workers' Deaths In High Rise Blaze

July 1, 2004
Related Articles:
Chicago Fire Department Says Burn Patterns Point To Human Cause Of Deadly High-Rise Fire
Chicago Fire Department Report Explains How Its Investigators Determined Cause
Expert: High-Rises Should Be Sprinklered
Fire Expert Testifies Chicago High-Rise Blaze Was Not Intentionally Set
Chicago FFs Testify They Saw Civilians In Co. Building Stairwell
Chicago Firefighters Testify In Cook County High-Rise Fire
NIST Reenacts High-Rise Fire
Fire Commissioner Accuses Commission Of Bias
Evacuation Procedure Not Followed During High-Rise Fire
Surveillance Tapes Show Inside Chicago High-Rise Fire
Chicago High-Rise Fire May Be Arson
Survivors of Chicago Fire Recall Escape
Witnesses Describe Frantic Scene
Chicago Official Pushes Fire Probe
FD Admits To Not Thoroughly Searching Stairs
Chicago Official Pushes Fire Investigation
FD Admits To Not Thoroughly Searching Stairs
Dueling Stories In Chicago Fire Investigation
Chicago Officials Continue to Defend Response
Chicago Fire Worries Wisconsin Fire Marshal
Ex-FEMA Head to Investigate Chicago Fire
Funeral Held For Man Killed In Chicago Fire
Lawsuits Filed In Chicago Building Fire
Chicago Fire Can Lead To Lessons
First Victim Of Chicago Fire Laid To Rest
Chicago Fire: Questions As Smoke Clears
Chicago Fire Dept. Catching Heat For Fire
8 Still Hospitalized After Chicago Fire
Fatal Fire Cancels Chicago, Events, Moves Scs.
Six Die In Chicago Building Fire

CHICAGO (AP) -- A Cook County commission investigating a deadly fire at a downtown high-rise will point to a series of mistakes by the Chicago Fire Department as factors in the deaths of six people, according to a published report.

The mistakes included fighting the fire from the wrong stairwell, directing fleeing employees to the wrong place and failing to seize control of a public-address system, the Chicago Sun-Times reported in Thursday's editions.

Although Fire Department protocol did not require it at the time, firefighters also failed to conduct a top-to-bottom stairway search while they fought the fire, causing a 90-minute gap between the time firefighters arrived on the scene and the time the six victims were found, the newspaper reported, citing a commission member who spoke on condition of anonymity.

Six people died and several others were injured in the Oct. 17 fire at the Cook County Administration Building.

Cook County Board President John Stroger appointed a panel of retired judges led by Abner Mikva to investigate the fire. They have held months of hearings, interviewing experts, engineers and fire officials.

Mikva declined to comment until the report is formally released next week, the Sun-Times said.

``I don't think it's healthy for the public to get this in dribs and drabs and leaks,'' Mikva said. ``It's healthier for the way the report gets digested if it all comes out at once. For all I know somebody might want to change their mind.''

Craig Antas, an attorney for the commission, said the full report will be released July 7.

``It's unfortunate that a portion of the commission's report was released. The most valuable thing is to release it in its entirety,'' Antas said.

He said the portions leaked to the Sun-Times were those most critical of the Fire Department and not necessarily indicative of the tone of the report as a whole.

According to the newspaper, the commission has determined the Fire Department should not have fought the fire from the southeast stairwell. Propping open the 12th-floor door to the stairwell blunted the ability of a ventilation system, known as a smoke tower, to pull smoke away from the stairs where the bodies were found.

Firefighters should also have directed people to the northwest stairwell, away from the smoke, the commission member told the newspaper.

The final report will also criticize the building engineer for his decision to evacuate, sending people down the smoke-filled stairs.

Despite an Office of Fire Investigations report that the fire was ``incendiary,'' the commission will conclude the cause was undetermined, the commission member said.

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Firehouse, create an account today!