Settlement Offer in Irmo, SC, LODD Calls for Firings, Apologies

The Irmo Fire District is demanding the terminations of the Columbia-Richland fire chief and assistant operations chief as well as a published public apology.

The Irmo Fire District has offered to resolve claims against it in a lawsuit over the 2023 death of firefighter James Michael Muller, but its proposal calls for the termination of Columbia’s Fire Chief Aubrey Jenkins and his Assistant of Operations Anthony Holloway, according to a court filing.

The offer, filed Nov. 16 in Richland County Common Pleas Court, also calls for Irmo Fire “to reimburse about $40,296 in legal fees and costs and for all claims against the district to be dismissed with prejudice.” It also demands “written apologies” by Jenkins and Holloway to be published in two South Carolina newspapers.

The proposal says “it is not an admission of liability” and gives the recipients 20 days to accept.

The required apologies would address allegations involving the investigation of the fatal fire. One, is being requested to be authored by Jenkins that would apologize for allegedly saying Irmo Fire or its employees gave false statements to an investigative agency.

Another, being requested would be authored by Holloway and would apologize for allegedly saying Sloane Valentino wrote the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health report. The offer says both apologies should be “submitted to The State and The Post and Courier for publication within 30 days of acceptance.”

Muller, 25, died after a Columbia apartment building collapsed during a May 2023 fire at the Tropical Ridge complex. He was one of four Irmo firefighters trapped in the collapse; three survived. His wife, Emma Elizabeth Muller, filed the lawsuit individually and as representative of his estate against the city of Columbia and Richland County. The city brought Irmo Fire District into the case as a third-party defendant.

A NIOSH report released in April 2025 cited communication failures, problems tracking firefighters at the scene and inadequate understanding of the building’s structural risks. The report said crews were not adequately informed that a second-floor area was sagging and described confusion among supervisors after the collapse.

The Irmo Fire District had released the report, with Chief Michael Sonefeld saying the department concurred with its findings and had taken steps to address the cited shortcomings, according to The State’s reporting.

If the settlement proposal is rejected by the city or expires, the case would continue toward trial.

©2026 The State. Visit thestate.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Firehouse, create an account today!