IAFC Backs Rights of Firefighters to Serve Multiple Organizations

The IAFC has released a statement that supports the rights of volunteer, career, or paid-on-call firefighters to serve multiple organizations or communities.

Read IAFC's Statement

CLEARWATER, Fla. -- The issue of "two-hatters" -- career firefighters who choose to serve as volunteers at another department -- has been a hot topic, as in recent years unions have tried to quash what used to be considered commonplace in many communities.

The IAFF's constitution and by-laws are written to keep union members from being volunteers within the work jurisdiction of an affiliate local.

On Friday, Oct. 31, the IAFC went against IAFF's stance on the issue, releasing a statement that supports the rights of volunteer, career, or paid-on-call firefighters to serve multiple organizations or communities.

IAFC's Board of Directors adopted the unified position during a board meeting in Washington, D.C. on Oct. 31 in conjunction with its Volunteer and Combination Officers Section.

The statement was made public at the Annual VCOS Symposium, which is being held this weekend in Clearwater, Fla.

"There has not been a strong position by (IAFC) in the past. The issue has been discussed for a number of years, but this is the first time there has been such a strong position on the issue," Salisbury, Md. Fire Chief David See, a member of the VCOS Board of Directors, said.

Mariposa County, Calif. Fire Chief Jim L. Wilson, a member of the VCOS Board of Directors, said the issue was first brought to the attention of the IAFC several years ago when two VCOS members -- who were also IAFF members as part of the D.C. Fire Department -- were brought up on charges by their local union for volunteering at another fire department.

"It really took a toll on those two guys," he said. "They were put in a position to fight with their own peers and argue with their own peers for the right to volunteer in their home community."

Stephen F. Miller Sr., Deputy Chief of the Cabin John Park Volunteer Fire Department in Montgomery County, Md. and Vice-Chair of the VCOS, was one of the firefighters who faced charges by the union.

"They charged every D.C. firefighter who was volunteering in P.G. or Montgomery County," he said.

Miller estimates that close to 30 D.C. firefighters were brought up on charges. He said that IAFF never further pursued the charges and timeframe to bring the case to trial eventually ran out.

"You had some that it affected and became less active as volunteers, but the funny thing was, when they published the list of names, we have a number of guys that called up and said 'I'm not on the list, I should be on the list.' So that was sort of funny."

IAFC's position comes at a time when more volunteer departments are being put under the microscope when it comes to quality of service and response time. Its members say that career firefighters help enhance community-based volunteer fire departments.

"Most of our members depend on career firefighters in one way or another to be the anchor in their departments," Wilson said. "Career firefighters do it everyday. They do it in their job, in their career; when they go home to their communities they bring a high level of response experience and training experience."

Wilson went on to say that it is in the IAFF's best interest to have as many members as possible, but that in the the rural areas of the country, the smaller communities that don't have an adequate tax base to support the expense of a career department, really have no choice but to try to stay with a volunteer department.

"There's a place for both. That's what our position is," he said. "We want to be able to take advantage of those people who are career firefighters that live in rural communities and want to give back by serving as a volunteer."

Fred C. Windisch, Chief of the Ponderosa, Texas Volunteer Fire Department and International Director of the VCOS said that his department currently employs six full time members, but believe that as it evolves, that will change.

"In my opinion, if patience were the driving force, there would be more IAFF jobs," he said. "In the normal course of events as departments evolve ... I would tend to say at some point -- I don't know when that is -- there will be an IAFF local in our fire department," he said. "But they can't come in and demand it too early in the evolution process of a combination department."

See believes that while the IAFF is doing its job by restricting its members from serving as volunteers, they are in turn doing a disservice to smaller career departments as they often recruit volunteers.

"The smaller- to mid-sized fire departments lean very heavily on the volunteer fire service. They really do look to volunteers to supply them with firefighters who have a grounding and understanding and some basic training.

"The union exists to benefit its members ... They're trying to expand and grow," he said. "I've never been a union member in the fire service and I could never understand why they would want to cut off the hand that is feeding them."

A spokesperson from the IAFF had no response to IAFC's position when contacted on Friday.

Related Links

IAFC Statement on Individuals' Rights to Serve Their Communities in Multiple Capacities
Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Firehouse, create an account today!