City Settles Discrimination Suit with Retired OH Firefighter

Retired Toledo Firefighter Geraldine McCalland received a $70,000 settlement in a suit against former chiefs and deputy chiefs.

The Blade, Toledo, Ohio
Toldeo Fire

Toledo officials reached a settlement with a retired female firefighter who joined with two others to sue the city for gender discrimination.

Geraldine McCalland, along with retired Capt. Carla Stachura and Pvt. Judi Imhoff, first filed suit 2005 in Lucas County Common Pleas Court, but a lengthy court process led to a dismissal. The case was refiled in July, 2015.

Specifically named in the lawsuit were former chiefs Michael Bell and Michael Wolever, along with former deputy chiefs John Coleman and Robert Metzger.

Private McCalland, whose recruit class was the first to hire women, said she was forced to work with an officer who made her feel unsafe and that she was penalized for taking sick leave.

Private McCalland withdrew from the suit Oct. 4, after the first day of the trial. She reached a $70,000 settlement with the city, a figure City Council unanimously approved this week. Money from the city’s risk management fund will cover the settlement.

“In some circumstances, it makes sense to explore settlement opportunities to minimize the exposure of the city if a jury were to view the case differently than we did. That’s what we did here,” City Law Director Dale Emch said.

A jury on Oct. 16 determined the city discriminated against Private Imhoff but not Captain Stachura. They awarded Private Imhoff $150,000 related to gender discrimination, finding she did suffer adverse employment action, but they denied claims of discrimination made by Captain Stachura. Claims of retaliation for both women also were denied.

Captain Stachura filed a notice of appeal Nov. 18.

Terry Lodge, the lawyer representing all three firefighters who sued, could not be reached for comment.


©2019 The Blade (Toledo, Ohio)

Visit The Blade (Toledo, Ohio) at

Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

More in Careers & Education