Federal officials said Monday they paid $12 million too much to about 3,500 people who applied for assistance because of hurricane damage.
The Federal Emergency Management Agency blamed the problem on a computer glitch and said officials were working to recoup the money.
Dan Craig, director of FEMA's recovery division, said the problem occurred throughout the state but he downplayed the error, saying the agency processed 1.2 million applications statewide.
Craig also defended allegations that FEMA paid millions in fraudulent disaster aid claims in Miami-Dade County, which missed a direct hit by a hurricane by 100 miles. FEMA paid about $30 million to more than 12,500 residents.
``Any home anywhere can be damaged by a hurricane,'' Craig said. He pointed out the widespread reach of the season's four hurricanes, which traveled throughout the country as smaller storms after hitting Florida.
Craig said Miami-Dade County received between 4 and 10 inches of rain during the week of Hurricane Frances and experienced winds between 55 and 80 mph from the storm.
The National Weather Service, part of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, reports that the wind speed in the county peaked at 36 mph on Sept. 4, when Frances hit, while the National Hurricane Center reported the maximum sustained wind at Miami International Airport was about 43 mph during Frances. The hurricane center reported no official rain gauges in Miami-Dade recording four inches of rain or more during the hurricane.
FEMA officials could not provide documentation to support their claims about the weather and had no comment on the discrepancies on Monday.
``This is a place where there was a heavy rainstorm and no hurricane,'' said Lale Mamaux, spokeswoman for U.S. Rep. Robert Wexler, D-Fla. ``The bottom line is there were millions of dollars in fraudulent payments made and we need to know who did this and why it happened. And we want to make sure people affected by the hurricane are compensated adequately.''
Lawmakers, including U.S. Sen. Bill Nelson, D-Fla., asked for an investigation into how FEMA distributed relief funds after the South Florida Sun-Sentinel reported that thousands of Miami-Dade County residents had collected hurricane aid.
In addition, the newspaper found that FEMA gave more than $70 million to residents of parts of Alabama, North Carolina and other areas barely touched by disaster. Members of Congress in those states called for a probe into the matter.
The U.S. Senate Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs, led by Chairwoman Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, announced last week it would investigate FEMA payments in Florida and other states.
``Now that there are reports coming from places other than Miami-Dade where moneys may have been distributed to individuals with little damage, we feel that raises serious questions about the way FEMA has managed and distributed its emergency relief funds,'' Nelson spokesman Bryan Gulley said.
Still, Craig said the claim that Miami-Dade County suffered no damage is ``an awfully false premise.''
Craig said FEMA inspectors personally inspect every claim for damage and that other entities had found evidence of damage in the county. Private insurers have paid $35 million for claims in Miami-Dade and the Small Business Administration has loaned more than $1.5 million in the county, Craig said.
