Neighbor Tried To Enter Burning Youngstown, Ohio House

Tears filled Ernest Cottle's eyes as he recalled his efforts to save his neighbor.
Dec. 27, 2004
2 min read
YOUNGSTOWN, Ohio (AP) -- Tears filled Ernest Cottle's eyes as he recalled his efforts to save his neighbor.

The 46-year-old man, called ``Big E'' by his friends, showed visitors a Christmas card Willa ``Cookie'' Payne had personally delivered on Tuesday. It was signed ``Cookie and Family.''

``I wasn't trying to be a hero, I was just trying to save her life.''

Firefighters found Payne, 57, dead on the dining room floor of her Youngstown home early Thursday. She lived alone in a two-story brick house, where the porch was decorated with candy canes for Christmas.

Fire Lt. Kevin Johnson said the fire, confined to the first-floor dining room, was apparently accidental. A smoke detector was inoperable. The victim was slightly burned and may have died from smoke inhalation, Johnson said.

``My daughter, Kandice, was on a chat line and looked out the window and saw the fire,'' Cottle said. ``She screamed, 'Daddy, Daddy, Miss Cookie's house is on fire!''' The Cottles live across the street.

Cottle said he grabbed a sledgehammer and tried to break open the front door of his neighbor's house. But the smoke was intense.

``I was trying to save her - her kids grew up with mine. She was like a sister - I can't believe it happened,'' he said. ``It just breaks your heart.''

Another neighbor, Laura Wylie, said she believes that Payne recently retired after 30 years working at Delphi Packard Electric.

Wylie said Payne had a lot of friends on the block.

``I can't believe she's gone,'' she said.

Sign up for our eNewsletters
Get the latest news and updates

Voice Your Opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of Firehouse, create an account today!